In the article "Darkness Too Visible" by Meghan Cox Gurdon, the issue of increasingly dark young adult (YA) literature is discussed. Gurdon states that YA literature has become overly mature and dark over the past few decades, and is in many cases inappropriate for "children" ages 12-18. She also writes that many themes are too suggestive or mature for a young adult audience. With these statements, Gurdon argues that much of YA literature is too dark (and possibly influential) for teenagers.
Gurdon uses many examples of loaded words and imagery to prove her point. The essay begins with an anecdote about Amy Freeman (a mother) shopping for a book for her teenage daughter. She leaves the store "empty-handed" because she believed that the selection of YA books was too dark for her 13-year-old. Gurdon describes Freeman feeling "thwarted and disheartened" during the situation. Additionally, the words "depravity", "lurid", and "grueling", as well as the phrases "ever-more-apalling", "unimaginable gore and cruelty", and "[bulldozing] coarseness or misery into [children's] lives" to describe YA literature. The perspective of an editor of YA literature opposed to "[compromising] how kids really talk" (censorship) is included and swiftly rebutted. Also, the opinion of a pro-censorship bookseller is included. Despite this, the perspective of an actual young adult is absent from the article. Gurdon wants her reader to be outraged at the content of YA literature.
I completely disagree with the content of this essay. Although YA literature has become increasingly "dark", it only mirrors the hardships and struggle ubiquitously present in real life. People opposed to the content of these books are only attempting to shelter those privileged enough to be spared from the horror depicted in many YA books. The only factual statement that I believe Gurdon make is that "Reading about homicide doesn't turn a man into a murderer...", which represents the counterpoint. In my opinion, this is the truth. YA books do not glorify the hardships presented within them. If the protagonist of a YA books is constantly doing drugs, chances are, there will be a consequence. Young adult literature is dark because teenagers no longer need to be sheltered from the real world. They need to know how the world works. They need to know that they may meet hardships and unimaginable struggle in their lives, and they need to know that it will get better.
Bruh, I really agree with your post on this. When you said that these dark themes are more present in books because we're no longer sheltered and that it mirrors hardships many struggle with, I agree a lot. Preach Zoe!
ReplyDeleteI agree! This was really good! Your writing was really strong, and you used some really loaded vocabulary! I loved how you pointed out all the flaws of the article, and in the end you kind of agreed with her in one of her points, and then you countered her. This was awesome!
ReplyDeleteAs usual, everything about your writing was superb. I comeprlety agree with your opinion.
ReplyDeleteI would have to agree with everyone! You have an amazing evidence to support your claim.
ReplyDeleteYour writing is very professional sounding I love it
ReplyDeleteI agree with your opinion. Your response was really good, and you used a lot of strong loaded words.
ReplyDeleteYou strongly elaborated on your evidence supporting your claim, and you pointed out what was wrong with the article. Nice work!
ReplyDelete