Firstly, Romeo fell in love with Juliet after only seeing her once, and never got to know anything about her. In Act 1, scene 5 (when Romeo first sees Juliet), he states "... I ne'er saw true beauty till this night." Romeo says nothing about Juliet's intelligence or personality, he only remarks on her beauty. Secondly, Romeo forgets his all-consuming "love" for Rosaline as soon as he meets Juliet, He says, "I have forgot that name and that name's woe." If Romeo can forget entirely the heavy sadness that plagued him for the beginning of the play, then he likely wasn't truly in love with Rosaline. Either this, or Juliet was Romeo's "rebound". Thirdly, Romeo is a teenager that tends to act rashly. For example, when Tybalt killed Mercutio, Romeo pursued and murdered Tybalt on an impulse. If Romeo tends to make rash, impulsive decisions, then it is very likely that he and Juliet were not truly in love.
Because of the way Romeo behaves throughout the play, I don't think he was truly in love with Juliet. Being teenagers, both Romeo and Juliet tend to act rashly. Also, Romeo is a romantic. This could mean that Romeo wanted love so badly that he decided to "fall in love" with the first beautiful girl he saw. In addition, he doesn't know Juliet at all. Romeo saw her, "fell in love" with her, kissed her, and married her. Nowhere in between these events did Romeo and Juliet try to get to know each other in any way. Because of the various behaviors and decisions displayed by Romeo, I don't think he was truly in love with Juliet.